Personal Insurance

Protect what you love

Cookie-cutter personal insurance plans are a fast-track to frustration. Our members deserve better. When you choose a personal plan through Members 1st Insurance Services, you get exactly that—a personal insurance plan, crafted by a real person who understands what you need and how to make it happen.

Coverage you need

Icon of two hands holding a heart
Coverage you need

Whether you are looking to protect your first home or your beloved pets, we’re here to get you the coverage you need. We offer a wide variety of coverage options from auto, home, renter’s and farm owner’s protection to personal insurance for things like your wedding, valuable items and more.

Icon of a piggy bank
Plans that save money

In situations where bundling could save you money, we're on it. But sometimes bundling isn't the best option—and we'll let you know that, too. We're just here to get you the best deal possible.

Icon of a hand with a percentage symbol
Discounts just for being a member

You might be surprised at just how affordable quality coverage can be. Many of the country's top carriers offer additional discounts for our members. And if you're happy with your current plan, don't worry—we even offer discounts on the insurance you already have.

Icon of a basket
Incredible selection, personalized

We'll compare options from more than 140 carriers—the largest network in our state—to find your perfect plan. You can rest easy knowing you've got the best coverage out there, and it's chosen just for you by an expert who understands your needs.

Icon of a coin on a computer screen
Online tools and support

There's no good reason why insurance should be confusing. So in addition to help and guidance whenever you need it, our mobile app makes payments easy and helps you understand your insurance costs as part of the bigger picture.

Icon of a laurel wreath
Transparent choices

We work for our members, not an insurance company. This means we're able to help you choose between a number of carriers to find the plan that best meets your needs and your budget. 

Learn More

Common Questions

We make it easy to pay your bill online, by mail or with automatic payments. You can pay monthly, quarterly or make one annual payment. Give us a call at (844) 498-6467 to learn more about your payment options.

If you need to file a claim, give us a call at (844) 498-6467. We'll walk you through everything you need to do.

Maintaining good credit is important, but the best way is to save is to review your policies and be sure you have the right amount of coverage. Contact us to get a free quote and ask about our member discounts. We have many payment options available, and you can always save money by paying your premium in full when it renews.

Many of our personal line carriers extend an additional discount to members. Call us at (844) 498-6467 today to learn more about all of the discounts that you may qualify for.

Icon of a star

Still have questions?

Our insurance team is here to make sure you get the plan that’s right for you. Connect with one of our experts online or stop by your nearest branch.

We're Here to Help

Getting Ready for Life's Moments and Milestones

Visa Signature® Card

Get 1.5% cash back (or 1.5 points) on every dollar you spend. On top of that, you get emergency medical coverage, trip interruption insurance, and Visa Signature Concierge Service—all with no annual fee.

Get Started

Buying a House

Your home will likely be the biggest investment you ever make. Here’s everything you need to know—and who to talk to if you’d like some personalized guidance.

Get Started

Goal Savings

Save for big plans—a little at a time. With great rates and powerful in-app tools, it’s never been easier to set (and achieve) your long-term goals.

Get Started


Protecting what you care about shouldn’t be complicated or unaffordable. We offer a full range of personal, group, auto, health, and life insurance plans through the most respected insurance companies in the business.

Get Started

Hit the Road

Hear that? It’s the open road calling. Here’s how to get an auto loan quicker and smarter.

Get Started

Off to College

Welcome to the start of a new beginning! Here's how to avoid student loans and make the most of saving for college.

Get Started